Skip to main contentSkip to solution

Today we can hardly conceive of ourselves without an unconscious. Yet between 17001700 and 19001900, this notion developed as a genuinely original thought. The "unconscious" burst the shell of conventional language, coined as it had been to embody the fleeting ideas and the shifting conceptions of several generations until, finally, it became fixed and defined in specialized terms within the realm of medical psychology and Freudian psycho analysis.

The vocabulary concerning the soul and the mind increased enormously in the course of the nineteenth century. The enrichments of literary and intellectual language led to an altered understanding of the meanings that underlie time-honored expressions and traditional catchwords. At the same time, once coined, powerful new ideas attracted to themselves awhile host of seemingly unrelated issues, practices, and experiences, creating a peculiar network of preoccupations that as a group had not existed before. The drawn-out attempt to approach and define the unconscious brought together the spiritualist and the psychical researcher of borderline phenomena (such as apparitions, spectral illusions, haunted houses, mediums, trance, automatic writing); the psychiatrist or alienist probing the nature of mental disease, of abnormal ideation, hallucination, delirium, melancholia, mania; the surgeon performing operations with the aid of hypnotism; the magnetizer claiming to correct the disequilibrium in the universal flow of magnetic fluids but who soon came to be regarded as a clever manipulator of the imagination; the physiologist and the physician who puzzled oversleep, dreams, sleepwalking, anesthesia, the influence of the mind on the body in health and disease; the neurologist concerned with the functions of the brain and the physiological basis of mental life; the philosopher interested in the will, the emotions, consciousness, knowledge, imagination and the creative genius; and, last but not least, the psychologist.

Significantly, most if not all of these practices (for example, hypnotism in surgery or psychological magnetism) originated in the waning years of the eighteenth century and during the early decades of the nineteenth century, as did some of the disciplines (such as psychology and psychical research). The majority of topics too were either new or assumed hitherto unknown colors. Thus, before 1790, few if any spoke, in medical terms, of the affinity between creative genius and the hallucinations of the insane.

Striving vaguely and independently to give expression to a latent conception, various lines of thought can be brought together by some novel term. The new concept then serves as a kind of resting place or stocktaking in the development of ideas, giving satisfaction and a stimulus for further discussion or speculation. Thus, the massive introduction of the term unconscious by Hartmann in 18691869 appeared to focalize many stray thoughts, affording a temporary feeling that a crucial step had been taken forward, a comprehensive knowledge gained, a knowledge that required only further elaboration, explication, and unfolding in order to bring in a bounty of higher understanding. Ultimately, Hartmann's attempt at defining the unconscious proved fruitless because he extended its reach into every realm of organic and inorganic, spiritual, intellectual, and instinctive existence, severely diluting the precision and compromising the impact of the concept.

Which one of the following statements best describes what the passage is about?

Solution

āœ… Correct Option: 2

We need to find the main theme that runs through the entire passage. Let us trace the key ideas step by step.

The passage starts by saying the "unconscious" developed as a new concept between 1700-1900. Then it shows how this single term brought together many different fields - spiritualists, psychiatrists, surgeons, philosophers, psychologists, etc. Finally, it explains how Hartmann used this term in 1869 to "focalize many stray thoughts" under one concept.

From passage: "Striving vaguely and independently to give expression to a latent conception, various lines of thought can be brought together by some novel term... Thus, the massive introduction of the term unconscious by Hartmann in 1869 appeared to focalize many stray thoughts"

The key insight -> the passage shows how one term (unconscious) gathered diverse, unrelated ideas from different fields into a single concept.


šŸ”“ Option 1 -> scope-error -> focuses only on "discovery of unconscious as part of mind" but passage isn't about discovering it, it's about how the term itself brought together different ideas from many fields

🟠 Option 3 -> too-broad -> talks about "growing vocabulary" in general, but passage specifically focuses on how one term (unconscious) unified different concepts, not vocabulary growth overall

🟠 Option 4 -> too-narrow -> mentions only "psychical research" but passage covers many different fields - psychology, medicine, philosophy, neurology, etc. all coming together under this term

🟢 Option 2 -> perfect-match -> captures exactly what passage describes - how diverse ideas from different fields got brought together under the single term "unconscious"

The confusion students have is between Options 1 and 2. But Option 1 talks about "discovering" the unconscious, while the passage is about how the word itself unified different ideas. Option 2 captures this unifying aspect perfectly.

Keyboard Shortcuts

  • Left arrow: Previous question
  • Right arrow: Next question
  • S key: Jump to solution
  • Q key: Jump to question